P: (614) 440-5454

  • Facebook - Black Circle
  • Instagram - Black Circle
  • Twitter - Black Circle

BANANA CREAM PIE

$38

This pie weighs 4.5 lbs! Loads of organic bananas in a vanilla pastry cream made with Snowville Creamery milk and organic sugar. Set in my classic all-butter flaky pie crust, topped with Snowville Creamery whipped cream. (Option to order with a graham cracker crust made with organic honey grahams).

BUCKEYE PIE (V, GF)

$40

A crunchy peanut crust, filled with dark chocolate ganache, then topped with a creamy peanut butter filling like the center of the best buckeye you've ever had. Finished with another drizzle of dark chocolate. Divine. Vegan, gluten free, and sweetened only with Ohio maple syrup!

COCONUT CREAM PIE

$38

Cool and creamy coconut pastry cream made with organic coconut milk, organic shredded coconut, and Snowville Creamery milk. Set in a crispy, flaky all-butter crust. Topped with lightly sweetened Snowville Creamery whipped cream and toasted coconut!

CHOCOLATE CREAM PIE

$40

A rich and creamy chocolate pie for true chocolate lovers. Silky smooth chocolate pastry cream sits on top of a layer of dark chocolate ganache in a crispy buttery crust, topped with Snowville Creamery freshly whipped cream.

CHOCOLATE COCONUT ALMOND PIE (V, GF)

$40

Vegan, made without gluten or refined sugar! Almonds, organic cacao powder, organic coconut, Ohio maple syrup, and gluten free oats are the only ingredients in this delicious & decadent pie! Not a fan of coconut? Make it a chocolate almond pie!

CHOCOLATE CHESS PIE 

$30

Like a delightfully dense brownie in a pie! Made with fair trade dark chocolate and a healthy does of organic cocoa powder. 

CHOCOLATE TART

$36

Almost half a pound of organic fair trade dark chocolate makes this deliciously rich and fudgy chocolate filling in a sweet short pastry crust. Make it extra decadent with a side of slightly sweetened Snowville Creamery whipped cream. Option to make it a raspberry chocolate tart ($38)

KEY LIME PIE

$36

One of the great American classics made with organic Cadia Honey Grahams, organic limes, and farm fresh eggs from Harrison Farm in Groveport Ohio. Or make it a lemon-lime pie and enjoy the best of both worlds.

LEMON ICE BOX PIE

$36

Perfect for anytime of the year! Delightfully refreshing and smooth lemon cream in a thick and crispy organic graham cracker crust. Perfect balance of sweet and tart.

MAPLE CREAM PIE 

$38

This pie is full of pure Ohio maple syrup! It starts with a crispy, flaky, buttery crust. That is filled with a maple pastry cream made as always with Snowville Creamery milk and Harrison Farm eggs. It is then topped with fresh maple whipped cream, and crispy maple pecans. The perfect combination of textures and flavors!

MAPLE PECAN PIE

$36

This is the pie that started it all. After years of detesting overly sweet pecan pie, I developed this recipe that turned me into a pecan pie-lover. And so began my obsession with creating the best pies possible. Made with Ohio maple syrup from Pleiades Maple Products in Mount Gilead OH, organic brown rice syrup, and toasted pecans. Perfect for your Thanksgiving table, or anytime of the year. 

NEPALI VEGGIE CURRY

HAND PIE $8

In-house chef Mayur makes the fillings for these savory Nepali hand pies. He has been perfecting his recipes for decades, and it shows. In the veggie he mixes local (when possible) and chemical free cabbage, potatoes, and carrots with his special spice blend. Something new for Columbus, mixing classic American pie crust with authentic Nepali cooking. Try some at the Bexley Natural Market or place an order for your parties! Buy some frozen to have on hand anytime! $46/half dozen

WHIPPED CREAM

$8/pint

Made with Snowville Creamery whipping cream and sweetened to perfection. Goes especially well with the chocolate tart... or just a spoon. Also available in brown sugar, cinnamon, and chocolate!