June Menu
All pies are made from scratch when you order!
Order at least one week in advance
Curbside pickup: 825 Kenwick Rd 43209 Weds-Sat 10am - 4pm
Delivery: $5 + $1/mile from above address
Pickup available at Bexley Natural Market on Fridays,
or select farmers markets Thursday-Saturday (see calendar)
Closed Sunday-Tuesday
Coming soon: Blueberry Pie!
Key Lime $36
The perfect balance of sweet and tart! Crunchy graham cracker crust made from Annie's organic honey grahams. Extra tart and creamy lime filling. Sweetened Snowville creamery whipped cream. Keep frozen to make it last, and serve partially frozen for an extra special treat!
Lemon Ice Box $36
Tart lemon cream in a thick graham cracker crust, topped with sweetened vanilla whipped cream
Strawberries and Cream Pie $38
Made with over one pound of local strawberries from Rock Dove Farm and Rhoad's Farm! Homemade vanilla wafer crust, topped with vanilla whipped cream. Bursting with flavor!
Buckeye Pie (V, GF) $40
Peanut crumb crust, dark chocolate ganache, creamy peanut butter filling sweetened only with maple syrup. Vegan and gluten free!
S'mores Pie $36
Graham cracker crust made with organic Annie's honey grahams, milk chocolate ganache with Theo fair trade organic chocolate, topped with toasted homemade marshmallow meringue. What a treat!
Rhubarb Pie $36
Made with freshly picked local rhubarb!
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie $36
A fleeting seasonal delight! Local strawberries from The Farmstead Market or Rock Dove Farm. Freshly picked organic rhubarb. Delicious!
Banana Cream Pie $38
This pie weighs over 4 pounds! Full of organic bananas, vanilla pastry cream made with Snowville Creamery milk, and topped with freshly whipped cream. All set in Ohio Pies' classic all-butter crust. Like the best banana pudding you've ever had, but better.
Coconut Cream $38
Made with organic coconut milk and toasted coconut, topped with Snowville Creamery freshly whipped cream and more toasted coconut. This one is joy in a pie for coconut lovers!
Chocolate Cream $40
Flaky all butter crust, chocolate ganache, rich and silky chocolate pudding, light and sweet whipped cream.
Chocolate chunk pecan cookies $30/dozen
Made with Theo organic fair trade chocolate & toasted pecans
Hand Pies $6-$8
Minimum order: 12 of one flavor. The perfect single serving of pie! Especially great for crust lovers. Flavors change with the seasons; ask about current flavors. *Can be made vegan!
Mini Pies $10-$12
Minimum order: 5 of one flavor. 5 inch pies, perfect for one or two people! Available in any of the current monthly flavors!
Cutie pies $4-$5
Minimum order: 12 of one flavor. The perfect bite size pie! Two inch (baked in a muffin tin), yet packed with fruit. Perfect for parties and for sharing! Available in current flavors with a traditional all-butter crust (not available with crumb-crust pies).