April Menu
All pies are made from scratch when you order!
Order at least 48 hours in advance
Large orders will require more time
Curbside pickup: 825 Kenwick Rd 43209 Mon-Sat 10am - 6pm
Delivery: $5 + $1/mile from above address
Pickup at Bexley Natural Market Tuesdays or Fridays
Closed Sundays
Coming soon: Rhubarb Pie!
Key Lime $36
The perfect balance of sweet and tart! Crunchy graham cracker crust made from Annie's organic honey grahams. Extra tart and creamy lime filling. Sweetened Snowville creamery whipped cream. Keep frozen to make it last, and serve partially frozen for an extra special treat!
Lemon Ice Box $36
Tart lemon cream in a thick graham cracker crust, topped with sweetened vanilla whipped cream
Lemon Meringue $40
An American classic. Tart lemon cream topped with a cloud of the most delicious toasty meringue. Made with organic lemons and Harrison Farm free range eggs.
Strawberries & Cream $38
Made with over one pound of Ohio strawberries from Rock Dove Farm! Cookie crust (made from homemade vanilla wafers) topped with sweet vanilla cream from Snowville Creamery. Bursting with flavor!
Mango Lassi Pie $38
Based off of the delicious Indian drink. Cookie crumb crust made with homemade vanilla wafers, mango curd, topped with a delightful yogurt whipped cream!
Passion Fruit $40
Cookie crumb crust, tart passion fruit curd, topped with lightly sweetend whipped cream
Buckeye Pie (V, GF) $40
Peanut crumb crust, dark chocolate ganache, creamy peanut butter filling sweetened only with maple syrup. Vegan and gluten free!
Chocolate Almond (V, GF) $40
Rich and fudgy. Toasted almond crust. Filling made with Theo organic fair trade dark chocolate and pure almond butter. Sweetened only with Ohio maple syrup.
S'mores Pie $36
Graham cracker crust made with organic Annie's honey grahams, milk chocolate ganache with Theo fair trade organic chocolate, topped with toasted homemade marshmallow meringue. What a treat!
Blueberry $36
Local organically grown blueberries from Blueberried Alive! Juicy, sweet and tart.
Cherry Pie $36
Tart Michigan cherries in a flaky all butter crust
Maple Pecan $36
Best seller. Wonderful depth of flavor, not too sweet, LOTS of toasted pecans. All butter crust.
Banana Cream $38
Vanilla pastry cream made with Snowville Creamery milk, tons of organic bananas, topped with sweetened vanilla whipped cream. One of Emily's favorites!
Coconut Cream $38
Made with organic coconut milk, toasted coconut & and Ohio's own Snowville Creamery milk and cream. If you love coconut, this one is joy in a pie.
Chocolate Cream $40
Flaky all butter crust, chocolate ganache, rich and silky chocolate pudding, light and sweet whipped cream.
Maple Cream $38
A maple lover's dream. Creamy maple pastry cream is topped with light and fluffy maple whipped cream. Sprinkling of maple toasted pecans on top for texture.
Mocha Cream $40
Flaky all butter crust, milk chocolate ganache, rich coffee pastry cream made with Snowville Creamery, topped with lucious chocolate whipped cream. Breakfast of champions!
Chocolate chunk pecan cookies $30/dozen
Made with Theo organic fair trade chocolate & toasted pecans
Vanilla Sugar Cookies $30/dozen
Old fashioned flavor. Vanilla bean & vanilla extract. Homemade royal icing with all natural food coloring. I have been tweaking this recipe for over three years because I believe sugar cookies should not only look good, they should taste good too! These are simply delicious.