This pie is a hidden gem on the Ohio Pies' menu. Made with 100% locally grown and organic sweet potatoes purchased from the Bexley Natural Market. The flavor of the sweet potato is highlighted by adding organic brown sugar, Minerva Dairy butter, a generous splash of pure vanilla extract, and no spice! The smooth and creamy custard pairs perfectly with the crisp and flaky all-butter crust. Store at room temperature for two days, then in the fridge. Best if eaten with two days of purchasing. Pies are 10 inches and serve 8 generous slices.


The last day to order a Non-Thanksgiving Pie for November is Wednesday Nov. 10th, 2021 at 5pm. November (Non-Thanksgiving) Order Pickup options:

  • 11/5 (10am-4pm) SOLD OUT
  • 11/6 (10am-4pm) SOLD OUT
  • 11/12 (10am-4pm)  SOLD OUT
  • 11/13 (10am-4pm) SOLD OUT


Pickup location for Non-Thanksgiving Pie for November is 825 Kenwick Rd, Columbus, OH 43209.

Sweet Potato Pie (November/Non-Thanksgiving)