Ohio Pies is a home bakery; there is no store front at this time. 

Whole Pies must be ordered ahead (Scroll down for current menu).

Smaller sizes can be found at local markets. See below for details!


Fresh deliveries every Tuesday.

For curbside pickup, preorder here:


2. Local Farmers Markets:

- Pearl Market every Friday

- Westerville Farmers Market every Saturday

- New Albany Farmers Market Thursdays once a month

- German Village Makers Market Sundays once a month

- Bexley Natural Market Farmers Market some Wednesdays

For PEARL MARKET, preorder here:

Order by Wednesday evening for Friday pickup

Curbside Pickup available

For WESTERVILLE, preorder here:

Order by Thursday 10 pm for Saturday pickup

3. FOR WHOLE PIES (10 inch) order HERE from the menu below. Monday-Saturday. Choose between curbside pickup (306 Clinton St  43202), pickup at a farmers market, OR delivery.

All flavors are made to order: Order at least 48 hours in advance!

Orders for Friday or Saturday must be placed by Wednesday 5pm.


*Most fruit pies can be made vegan upon request*

Apple $36

Banana Cream $38

Blackberry $36

Blueberry $36

Brownie Pie $36

Buckeye (V, GF) $40

Cherry $36
Chocolate Almond (V, GF) $40

Chocolate Coconut Almond (V,GF) $40

Chocolate Cream $40

Coconut Cream $38

Ice Box Key Lime $36

Lemon Ice Box $36

Maple Pecan $36

S'mores Pie $36

Strawberries & Cream $38

Available Frozen (Take & Bake):

Nepali Curry Hand Pies $8 each or $88/1dz

Mini Pot Pies $12 - $16

Single Pie Crust $10

Double Pie Crust $15

Odds & Ends

Seasonal Hand Pies $33/half dz OR $66/dz

Seasonal Sugar cookies $30/dz

Crispy Chewy Chocolate Chip Cookies $30/dz

Snowville Whipped Cream $8/pint






P: (614) 440-5454

  • Facebook - Black Circle
  • Instagram - Black Circle
  • Twitter - Black Circle