Happy Thanksgiving!!

Ohio Pies is closed

Thursday 11/26 through Sunday 11/29

Ohio Pies is a licensed home bakery: There is currently no storefront

Deliveries every Tuesday to Bexley Natural Market 

Curbside pickup 306 Clinton St 43202 or delivery Monday-Saturday

All flavors made to order: Order at least 48 hours in advance

Place order HERE


Apple $36

Apple Crumb $36

Banana Cream $38

Black and White $42

Blackberry $36

Blueberry $36

Buckeye (V, GF) $40

Chai Pie $38

Cherry $36

Chocolate Tart $36
Chocolate Almond (V, GF) $40

Chocolate Coconut Almond (V,GF) $40

Chocolate Cream $40

Coconut Cream $38

Ice Box Key Lime $36

Lemon Ice Box $36

Maple Cream $38

Maple Pecan $36

Pumpkin $36

Samoa $38

Sweet Potato $35

S'mores Pie $36

Take & Bake:

  • Nepali Curry Hand Pies $8 each or $88/1dz

  • Mini Pot Pies $12 - $16

  • Double All Butter Pie Crust $15

  • Single Pie Crust $10:

       -Classic All Butter (Grass-fed Ohio Butter)

       -Graham cracker (organic Annie's Honey Grahams)

       -Cookie Crumb (Homemade Vanilla Wafers) 

       -Buckeye GF, V (Roasted Peanuts, GF Oats)

       -Almond GF, V (Roasted Almonds, GF Oats)

       -Almond Coconut GF, V (Roasted Almonds, Toasted Coconut)

Small Pies

Available in most current flavors

1. Mini Pies $10

5 inch (Equal to 2 slices)

Minimum order: 4 of one flavor

2. Cutie Pies $4-5

2 inch (Bitesize, equal to a mini muffin)

Minimum order: 1 dz of one flavor

Odds & Ends

Seasonal Hand Pies $33/half dz OR $66/dz

Seasonal Sugar cookies $30/dz

Chocolate Chunk Pecan Cookies $30/dz

Cinnamon & Sugar Crust Cookies $5/4 ounce bag

Snowville Whipped Cream $8/pint

"That is the single best bite of pie I have ever had." 

- Andy Dubyoski, Chef, Cleveland OH 






P: (614) 440-5454

  • Facebook - Black Circle
  • Instagram - Black Circle
  • Twitter - Black Circle